Menu
HomeTariffeWebinar
Connexion
Contatti
Contatti

Responding to a retailer’s specification without giving away your margin

What a central purchasing body is entitled to demand, what is negotiable, and what costs more to supply than to refuse. How to read a traceability/quality specification without simply submitting to it.

3 min
Two columns: on the left what the law imposes and is not negotiable, on the right the retailer’s internal policy, which is — audits, data-exchange formats, volumes, penalties.
Confusing the two columns costs you twice: by accepting a commercial requirement as mandatory, and by negotiating what the law imposes — VeraTrace diagram

A retailer's specification (cahier des charges) often arrives as a closed document: sign it as it stands, or do not get listed. In practice, part of its content reflects a genuine regulatory obligation, another part reflects the retailer's internal policy, which is negotiable, and a third part is sometimes simply copied from an earlier specification with no connection to the product concerned. Telling the three apart changes how you respond.

What is non-negotiable: regulatory obligations

Some clauses restate a legal obligation that already applies, with or without the specification:

  • One-step-back/one-step-forward traceability (Regulation 178/2002) — already owed, whoever the customer.
  • The health thresholds (temperature, use-by date) specific to the product family.
  • Mandatory labelling particulars (INCO, allergens, origin where required).

These requirements are not negotiable — they apply in any case. A specification that lists them is merely documenting what is already owed.

What is negotiable: the retailer's internal policy

Other clauses go beyond the legal minimum, by the retailer's choice. They are legitimately open to discussion:

  • Audit frequency: an annual on-site audit is common; a quarterly audit for a small order volume is disproportionate and can be negotiated down, or replaced by documentary checks between two physical audits.
  • The data-transmission format: full EDI required for a few pallets a month costs more to set up than a simple structured submission (standardised spreadsheet, lightweight API). The format should be proportionate to the actual volume.
  • Required third-party certifications: some overlap with each other (two labels covering the same scope) — it is legitimate to ask which of the two is sufficient.
  • Replenishment lead times: often calibrated for an industrial supplier, to be adapted for seasonal or small-scale production.

What to cost before signing

Three questions to ask yourself before accepting an expensive clause:

  1. Is the cost of compliance recouped by the order volume on offer? An expensive digital traceability system to satisfy a single retailer on a small volume may never pay for itself.
  2. Does the investment serve beyond this customer? A requirement aligned with a widely shared standard (GS1, a common sector format) benefits your whole commercial activity; a requirement proprietary to a single retailer benefits only that retailer.
  3. What happens in the event of a minor non-conformity? A specification that provides for a disproportionate penalty for a minor deviation (a one-day delay, a labelling error with no health risk) deserves discussion before signing, not discovery at the first incident.

What costs more to supply than to refuse

Some requirements, taken in isolation, seem reasonable but become disproportionate relative to the actual volume of business:

  • A dedicated data-exchange system for a few orders a quarter.
  • An expensive international certification for a solely local or regional outlet.
  • A minimum-volume commitment incompatible with actual seasonal production.

In these cases, refusing or proposing a proportionate alternative protects the margin better than a listing obtained at a loss.

How to respond, in practice

  1. Read the specification clause by clause, distinguishing legal obligation from internal policy.
  2. Identify the clauses that are disproportionate given the volume actually on offer.
  3. Respond in writing on the points to negotiate, before signing — never with a verbal agreement followed by signing the document as it stands.
  4. Cost the compliance and compare it with the margin expected on the contract.
  5. Check what happens in the event of a minor deviation before signing, not after the first incident.

Common mistakes

  • Signing without reading every clause, leaving the reading to a non-technical person who does not spot disproportionate requirements.
  • Negotiating after the first incident rather than before signing — the balance of power is far less favourable once committed.
  • Investing in a system proprietary to a single retailer rather than in a standard reusable across your whole commercial activity.

Cosa cambia per Lei

Lo stesso ragionamento non si gioca nello stesso punto a seconda del vostro posto nella filiera.

Lei è un produttore

A specification is not a block to accept or refuse as a whole. This guide sets out which clauses are genuinely non-negotiable and which are open to discussion — before signing, not after.

VeraTrace per i produttori →

Lei trasforma, è un marchio

Some requirements (audit frequency, data format) cost more to meet than they bring in order volume. The section “what costs more to supply than to refuse” helps you put a figure on it before committing.

VeraTrace per i trasformatori →

Lei è un distributore o una centrale d’acquisto

A specification disproportionate for a small supplier closes the door to producers the purchasing body would nonetheless like to list. This guide, written from the supplier’s side, also helps calibrate what you ask for.

VeraTrace per la distribuzione →

Concetti trattati

Comment ces textes sont écrits