Upstream and downstream traceability: the difference explained simply
Upstream, downstream, internal: the three notions most often confused by an operator discovering the regulation, with concrete examples for each and what “one-up, one-down” really means.

“Upstream traceability”, “downstream traceability”, “internal traceability”: three terms that Regulation (EC) No 178/2002 lays down without always defining them as clearly as one might wish. This guide takes each one separately, with a concrete example, to clear up the ambiguity once and for all.
The basic rule: “one-up, one-down”
Article 18 of Regulation 178/2002 requires every food business operator to know two things, and only two:
- Who supplied them with each product, ingredient or substance going into a foodstuff.
- To whom they sold or delivered each product.
This is the so-called “one-up, one-down” rule: one link upstream, one link downstream. The regulation does not require knowing the primary origin of the material (the field, the livestock farm) or the final consumer — only the immediately neighbouring link, in both directions.
Upstream traceability: where it comes from
Upstream traceability answers a single question: who supplied me with this lot? In concrete terms, for a baker who receives a sack of flour, upstream traceability stops at the miller who delivered that sack — not at the wheat field that produced it, unless the baker chooses to go further for commercial reasons or to comply with a specific set of product specifications.
What must be kept, at a minimum: the name and address of the supplier, the nature and quantity of the product received, and the date of receipt.
Downstream traceability: where it goes
Symmetrically, downstream traceability answers: to whom did I sell this lot? For the same baker, it means knowing to which direct customers (individuals buying directly, restaurants, grocery shops) a lot of bread made from that sack of flour was sold, and when.
It is downstream traceability that makes a recall possible in practice — without it, a defective product cannot be found once it has left the premises, however good the upstream traceability is.
Internal traceability: the link the regulation does not name
Neither upstream nor downstream, internal traceability links an incoming lot to an outgoing lot within the same business, when processing takes place. Regulation 178/2002 does not explicitly require it — but without it, an operator may know their flour supplier and their bakery customers without being able to say which precise sack of flour went into which lot of bread sold to which customer. The chain breaks in the middle, exactly where a recall needs it most.
In concrete terms, internal traceability means numbering each production lot and keeping, for each outgoing lot, the list of incoming lots that contributed to making it.
A complete example, from field to plate
- Upstream: the flour mill knows which wheat silo a lot of flour comes from.
- Upstream (next link): the baker knows which flour mill their sack of flour comes from.
- Internal: the baker knows which sack of flour went into which lot of the day’s bread.
- Downstream: the baker knows to which customers (the local restaurant, the grocery shop) that lot of bread was delivered.
Each link knows only its immediate neighbours — which is precisely what makes the system workable at scale: nobody needs to know the whole chain, only their own segment, provided that each segment is properly documented.
Common mistakes
- Confusing “upstream” with “complete origin”. The regulation does not require tracing back to the original field or livestock farm, only to the immediate supplier — even if going further back is sometimes commercially useful.
- Neglecting internal traceability in the belief that the “one-up, one-down” rule is enough once processing takes place — it is precisely this link that the rule does not cover.
- Keeping only upstream traceability, the most intuitive kind, while neglecting downstream — even though it is downstream traceability that makes a recall workable.
Checklist
- For each receipt, keep the supplier, the nature of the product, the quantity and the date.
- For each dispatch, keep the customer, the nature of the product, the quantity and the date.
- As soon as processing takes place, link each outgoing lot to the incoming lots that made it up.
- Check that these three links can be produced in a few minutes, not a few days.
Was das für Sie ändert
Dieselbe Überlegung stellt sich je nach Ihrer Stellung in der Kette an anderer Stelle.
Sie sind Erzeuger
You are already required to know your immediate supplier and your immediate customer — this guide clarifies what that really covers, and what it does not.
VeraTrace für Erzeuger →Sie verarbeiten, Sie sind eine Marke
Internal traceability, which links an incoming lot to an outgoing lot after processing, is not explicitly defined by the regulation — this guide explains why it becomes indispensable as soon as a recipe exists.
VeraTrace für Verarbeiter →Sie sind Händler oder Einkaufszentrale
A supplier who confuses upstream and downstream often answers beside the point of a traceability request. This guide gives the exact vocabulary to use so as to leave no room for ambiguity.
VeraTrace für den Handel →